Before you brief — the questions to answer internally
Be honest about four things. The audience — who specifically should be in the room. The outcome — what changes if this event works. The constraint — what cannot move (date, venue, talent, message, coverage). The budget — a real range, not a placeholder. Briefs that name these four are answered well; briefs that don't get formulaic proposals back.
Five questions that separate serious agencies from theatre
1. 'Can you reframe our problem in your own words before proposing a format?' Agencies that reframe well are the ones who'll produce well. Agencies that go straight to format selection are managing perception, not solving problems.
2. 'Which specific venues have you produced in over the last 12 months in this city?' Real venue access is named in specifics, in seconds. Generic answers ('we have a strong venue network') signal absence.
3. 'Who is the named production lead and what are they accountable for end-to-end?' One person, one accountable scope. Layered account teams without a single lead are a structural problem.
4. 'What does your contract include — and what comes as a separate line item?' Permits, insurance, AV, post-event media. Hidden line items destroy budget discipline.
5. 'What's a recent project you'd do differently?' Agencies who can answer this honestly are mature. Agencies who can't are still selling.
Red flags
Generic case studies that don't name venues, audiences, or outcomes. Account-team-heavy proposals with no named production lead. Reluctance to share budget ranges before signed NDAs. Unprompted insistence on a specific format ('we should do a dinner') before understanding your audience or outcome. Slide decks that recycle the same campaign work for three different agencies.
Evaluating proposals fairly
Three filters. Quality of reframe — did they engage with your actual problem? Quality of named specifics — venues, vendors, talent, formats, by name. Quality of trade-off honesty — every good proposal makes real trade-offs and explains them. Strip out everything else (presentation polish, case-study count) and decide on these three.
